Catholic men of America — and all conservatives who support them — you’re not going to win this debate. You are not going to deprive American women of the benefits of 21st Century science, medicine, and law. You are not going to inject your archaic religious beliefs into American jurisprudence and drag women back into the Dark Ages.
We know about birth control and contraception and family planning and reproductive health. We know about unwanted children, poverty-stricken unwed mothers, irresponsible fathers, ectopic pregnancies, STDs, HIV/AIDS, and a variety of “female conditions,” and we know there are ways to avoid, prevent, or cure them. We know we don’t have to bear and give birth to the results of rape or incest. We know we don’t have to remain “barefoot and pregnant” during our most productive years, serving as mere baby factories for our men. We know we can plan our families and engage in fulfilling lives and careers outside the home if we wish. We won’t go back to the days before we had these options.
You would return America’s women to the era of coat-hanger abortions just so you can crow about how saintly you are!? What about those who don’t share your beliefs? What about the separation of church and state? What about “Christian” charity and kindness and love for your fellow man and woman? What about respect for others?
It’s no wonder the Catholic Church is losing its grip in America. It’s no wonder the GOP is becoming marginalized. When raw power is the only goal, when sheer dominance is the only objective, when illegally imposing antiquated irrelevant religious beliefs on the majority is the sole purpose of proposed legislation, you will fail. This is America. We are a democracy. We have a constitutional right to freedom of (and by implication, from) religion. We have a solid wall between church and state.
This is not a discussion about contraceptives. This is not a discussion about insurance, or who pays for what. This is not about a “war on religion.” This is about an attack on the rights of half the U.S. population. This is an all-out war on women.
So take your religious beliefs back to your own pews and churches and keep them there. They do not belong in any legislation in the United States of America.
______________________________________
Also on Pied Type:
Embryos gain personhood in Oklahoma
Santorum: Raped? Pregnant? It’s a gift
Semantics in law and religion
Komen relents, sort of
Senators ask Komen Foundation to reverse decision
Happy Birthday, Roe V. Wade
Plan B: Politics trumps science
Related articles
- Birth-Control Hearing Was ‘Like Stepping Into a Time Machine’ (abcnews.com)
- Absence of women at birth-control hearing prompts larger question (washingtonpost.com)
- Rick’s Lucky Culture War (thedailybeast.com)
- Reproductive Rights (writerhughes.wordpress.com)
- Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: GOP can’t control backlash to birth control “strategy” (dailykos.com)
- CNN Hits Santorum for His Religious Beliefs (newsbusters.org)
- Religion in Politics – Praying While Preying on the People (planetpov.com)
- Contraceptive controversy gets ugly (whitehouse.blogs.cnn.com)
- Religious Liberty for Dummies (truthonthemarket.com)
- Freedom of and From Religion – by Bill Moyers (jhaines6.wordpress.com)
- Lauren Brown Jarvis: Religious Liberty vs. Reproductive Liberty: A New Political Minefield Pits Women Against the Church (huffingtonpost.com)
- The War on Women: Accommodation and Compromise? Medical Care is a Right, not a Privilege (skydancingblog.com)
- All-male picture tells 1,000 words, say backers of birth control policy (thehill.com)
- The Catholic Church’s role in health-care delivery (seattletimes.nwsource.com)
- Religion, The Government, and Contraception (socyberty.com)
- Has H.G. Wells’ Time Machine Suddenly Taken Us Back to Pre-1920? (findingannmacgregor.com)
- Evening Reads: Outrageous…bloody outrageous! (skydancingblog.com)
- Issa Defends Denying Female Witness At Contraception Hearing: She ‘Wasn’t In Any Way Related’ (thinkprogress.org)
- Robert Walker: Do Something Special This Year for Valentine’s Day (huffingtonpost.com)
- Robert Walker: The Santorum Strain (huffingtonpost.com)
- May We Please Keep Talking About Family Planning Until November?: Garry Wills Smacksdown E.J. Dionne Watch (delong.typepad.com)
It’s funny how the extremists are attempting to claim, as the basis for their discrimination, the “right to religious freedom.” I can’t help but be reminded of past attempts to justify the denial of human rights…
“[T]here can be no such thing as the “right” of some men to violate the rights of others.” – Ayn Rand: Racism. Those words were aimed at the extremists, on both sides, of the Racism debate back in to 1960s, but I believe they hold true for this debate as well.
Absolutely. Your right to swing your fist ends where my nose begins.
Yes.
Men need to stay out of women’s health issues. (Pregnancy is not a disease – Nor does “preventative health issues” have anything to do with pregnancy)
Women are quite capable of choosing a doctor and managing their own health issues with their doctor – without government or church direction.
The Federal government needs to stay out of religious institution’s beliefs and should also stop telling women what they do or do not need (and how to think)
Women are not idiots or children that need / want their “guidance” (no matter how well meaning)
Back off – both sides.
So let me rephrase: Your right to brandish your authority ends where my uterus begins.
So true….Should we make bumper stickers and banners? Just had it.
In the past I have made custom bumper stickers at zazzle.com. I may have to do some new ones … if someone hasn’t already done something appropriate.
Outstanding post, Pied. It could well serve as a Congressional speech on the subject. Or, dare I say it, even a sermon? But forget that – no collar for the likes of you!
Thanks. I’m afraid I could never deliver this as a speech. I’d get way too emotional and be written off as “just another hysterical woman.” Besides, these troglodytes aren’t letting women testify.
That was the salt in the wound. I really have no respect for it.
Nor I. I read that the panel was all church leaders because the discussion was about a “war on religion.” More salt, served up with an insult to my intelligence.
Well written Pied. To add further insult to our intelligence the pseudo-pious have the nerve to condemn the islamists for similarly ancient [and obviously more anti-female] ideology.
It’s a conspiracy that goes well beyond all the fake religious dogmas. In addition to keeping women down, the [absurdly ironically named] “pro-life” effort also ensures population growth. Thus maintaining our armed forces. Soldiers have to be born and raised to enlistment age.
That would at least explain why Santorum claims birth control is dangerous.
the “pro-life” appellation certainly is misplaced, isn’t it. I guess it’s too late, as someone pointed out on my blog, to re-claim it for those of us who believe in supporting the life of the already living.
No, that ship has sailed. What we probably need to do is come up with a new, catchy, appropriate name for them and then use it until it sticks. It needs to be something the media will pick up and use.
Woo-hoo!!!! Love it! So well said, PT!!!
Thx. You’ve had some pretty great commentary on the subject over at your place, too.
Yeah, I kinda blew up the other day. And still haven’t calmed down much since then. Especially after Santorum’s idiotic comments about Obama and religion.
Don’t calm down! Women shouldn’t calm down unless and until Santorum and all those like him get far, far away from Washington politics.