Skip to content

‘Qualified’ and ‘experienced’ work for me

resumeSupreme Court Justice David Souter has announced his retirement from the court and the fallout has been what one would expect.

The media can’t stop talking about it, mentioning possible nominees for the opening, giving us blow-by-blow histories of SCOTUS decisions and which judges expressed which opinions on each, Souter’s record, and even biographies, as though we were meeting him for the first time.

The Republicans are denigrating the still-unnamed nominee as too liberal, unworthy, a presidential yes-man or -woman, a judicial activist, etc. It doesn’t matter who ends up being the nominee; it only matters that the nominee will be named by a Democratic president.

The Democrats are saying the nominee must be a woman, a minority, a liberal, etc.

Here we go again with the affirmative action thing. Why must the nominee be any of these things? There are only nine Supreme Court justices — human beings all. It is impossible to divvy them up in a way that represents every segment of our population — black, white, Hispanic, male, female, liberal, conservative. What about Swedes? Gays? Hearing-impaired? Libertarians? Redheads? Youth? Little people? High school dropouts? Veterans? Vegans?

“Affirmative action” or “quota.” Whatever terminology you prefer, in a nation as diverse as ours, the concept is ridiculous on its face. No single entity is large enough to fairly represent all of us. No school or university, no profession, no political party.

And certainly not a group of only nine people.

1 Comment »

  1. Yes, and the next judge must have empathy. Did you see Stephen Colbert’s take on the word “empathy?” It was hilarious!
    I don’t remember it right off hand, but I watch him every night, so I’m sure I saw it. Stewart and Colbert are on here from midnight to 1 am, so I’d hate to be quizzed on what I see.

"Nothing is more dangerous than ignorance and intolerance armed with power." ~ Voltaire

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: