birth tourism

‘Birth tourism’ perverting the system


birth tourism
Click to view this video on MSNBC website — Websites target birth tourists”Birth tourism.” I first heard about it a while back, but at the time it was just an obscure idea said to be catching on in China

Silly me. I should have known. If the Chinese saw the potential, so would everyone else in the world. That’s a lot of people gaming the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution to grab citizenship for their babies. Pregnant? Come to the U.S. to give birth and your baby will automatically be an American citizen. Then go home and enjoy life until that baby grows up and decides to seek a job or education in the U.S., or family members decide to apply for green cards.

More than one bill has been proposed in Congress that requires one of the baby’s parents be a citizen or legal resident in order for the baby to become a citizen. That doesn’t strike me as unreasonable. But to date the bills have gone nowhere. Nor have proposed constitutional amendments with the same objective.

An interesting discussion of birthright citizenship on the website Center for Immigration Studies concludes:

Extending 14th Amendment birthright citizenship to any class of persons is a momentous matter because it confers very valuable benefits and imposes very serious obligations on children who have no say in the matter and it also has long-lasting and important effects on the size and composition of the U.S. population. The executive branch’s current practice of extending birthright citizenship to nonresident aliens has never been authorized by any statute or any court decision. The legislative record left by drafters of the 14th Amendment shows that they were primarily concerned about conferring citizenship on freed slaves. While the Supreme Court has settled the matter as it applies to permanent resident aliens, it has yet to decide the matter as it applies to aliens whose presence in the United States is temporary or unlawful. As a result, Americans are justifiably upset with a policy that has become standard practice without their approval.

At least most of the illegal immigrants who sneak into the country plan to stay and raise their “anchor babies” here. Birth tourism is such a blatant gaming of our laws that I can’t imagine anyone here would condone it. And yet they do.

I understand the original intent of the 14th Amendment — making it clear that freed slaves were citizens — and I object to broadening it to mean handing out citizenship willy nilly to anyone whose parents manage to push, pull, or drag themselves into this country just in time and just long enough to give birth. I put a much higher value on U.S. citizenship.

foreign mothers
Click to view this video on MSNBC website — Foreign women travel to America to give birth

Note, 11/14/2011: Some Chinese women, in order to circumvent their country’s one-child policy, come to the U.S. to have a second or third child. Apparently when they return to China, these children, being U.S. citizens, are not subject to the law. While I sympathize with these women and their desire to have more children, this is not the purpose or intent of U.S. citizenship.


2 thoughts on “‘Birth tourism’ perverting the system

  1. The scope of this surely can’t be too great because the parents need to be pretty wealthy to afford it, do they not?

    Nevertheless, birth tourism does seem like a clear perversion of the law. Sounds like there needs to be a public debate, followed by fixing this as needed along with the entire mess that constitutes our current immigration policies.

    America needs fruit pickers and care givers more than pampered children of rich people who make their living at the capital-gains tax rate, IMHO.

    1. The report mentioned $30,000 at some point. I don’t recall if that was some kind of average or the price of one of the “tour package/citizenships” being sold. That’s what it amounts to: citizenship for sale. And there are vendors and facilitators at both ends of the line making money off these “tourists.”

... and that's my two cents