Plan B: Politics trumps science

Something disturbing happened in Washington this week. No, it wasn’t election related. It wasn’t even Congress related.

It was a single individual, Katherine Sebelius, Secretary of Health and Human Services, deciding to overrule the FDA and its determination that Plan B, an emergency “morning after” contraceptive, is safe to be sold without a prescription to any female of child-bearing age. Rather than yield to science and logic, Sebelius decided the drug should continue to be kept behind pharmacy counters instead of being openly available on store shelves, and dispensed only to women 17 and older who have either a prescription or proof of age.

Plan BWe have children raising children in America, often in poor communities, due to lack of education, lack of access to proper health care, lack of adult advice and supervision, or all of the above. We also have pregnancies occurring when other birth control methods fail, or in cases of rape and incest. These things shouldn’t happen, but they do. Kids shouldn’t be having sex, but they do. Kids should go to their parent(s) or doctor if they think they are pregnant, but for any number of reasons, they don’t. That’s the reality, and denying it changes nothing. If it did, America’s teen pregnancy problem would not exist.

There are parents who don’t want Plan B available to their 13-year-old because they, the parents, “want to know”; they want to know if their daughter gets pregnant. Of course they do. But their knowing wouldn’t change anything; their child would still be pregnant. More than likely, they just want to feel like parents, like they are involved in the process and in control of what their 13-year-old does. That’s a normal parental response, but obviously if the child is seeking Plan B, the parent has been out of the loop for a while. Better to equip the child with the knowledge to protect herself and hope she doesn’t need it than to not prepare her and end up with an unwanted pregnancy.

Given the reality of life in the U.S. today, the number of teen pregnancies we have, and the scientific research confirming the safety of Plan B, there seems only one reason for Sec. Sebelius to have overruled the FDA: personal politics. This is the first time any HHS secretary has overruled an FDA decision on drug safety and use. Worse, and incomprehensibly, Pres. Obama supported her decision.

Francesca Grifo, director of the Union of Concerned Scientists’ Scientific Integrity Program, commented:

Secretary Sebelius, a non-scientist, overruled the conclusions of an independent scientific panel that arrived at its decision after careful analysis and consideration of the data. Plan B is considered safe for over-the-counter use not only by FDA scientists and advisors but also by countless esteemed medical associations, from the American Academy of Pediatrics to the American Medical Association.

The secretary’s decision undermines the ability of FDA to make drug approval decisions based on the best available science. The president’s support for the secretary’s decision is unfortunate, as it is inconsistent with his own March 2009 memorandum on scientific integrity.

That memorandum states, in part: “The public must be able to trust the science and scientific process informing public policy decisions. Political officials should not suppress or alter scientific or technological findings and conclusions.”

It was a bad decision by Sebelius and a bad decision by Obama. It is also another blow in the ongoing war on reproductive rights and choice. Should children be buying Plan B? Ideally, they shouldn’t need to. Ideally they shouldn’t be facing such a decision — and certainly not without parental input. But as long as kids have sex or are sexually abused and don’t or can’t seek help from the adults in their lives, Plan B will be preferable to children having children.

Someone named DCMike commented on the Huffington Post:

“Plan B gives young women a tomorrow that belongs to them. Let them have it.”

I would say the same for all birth control, all contraceptives, and all family planning resources.



Categories: Health, Law, Obama, Politics, Sci Tech, war on women

Tags: , ,

8 replies

  1. “That’s a normal parental response, but obviously if the child is seeking Plan B, the parent has been out of the loop for a while. Better to equip the child with the knowledge to protect herself and hope she doesn’t need it than to not prepare her and end up with an unwanted pregnancy.”

    That’s an interesting point. If the concern is that parents want to have a say (or at least knowledge) about their daughter’s sexual activity, that is a thing that should be in place well before something as dire as needing Plan B happens. Its interesting the “family values” party wants to keep kids away from sex education AND the solution to the problems a lack of sex education causes….

  2. Back after my divorce, when I was out there in the jungles of dating, one of those “getting to know you” conversations with a man turned to the topic of his 14-year-old daughter. “She would never get pregnant because she knows I’d beat her senseless if she did,” he said.

    Yeah. No. Kicked that guy to the curb not 10 minutes later, after I confirmed that what I was hearing was not a joke.

    Parents like that jerk are the reason Plan B should be available without parental consent, to girls younger than 17, over-the-counter.

    • On a less violent-sounding but similar note, in a well-respected, two-parent suburban family the mere shame of an accidental teenage pregnancy might keep a girl silent until the problem becomes obvious to everyone. “Thou shalt not disappoint thy parents” is a fearsome thing to many kids.

  3. Why does it seem so appropriate that Kansas (Sebelius) is somehow intertwined in this choice/life political debate?
    The sad part? The circus of the GOP race has already drowned out any debate about this.

    • I hadn’t thought about Sebelius being from Kansas, but yes, that probably weighed heavily in her decision. I’m from Oklahoma, and the conservatism in that part of the country is bedrock. It’s a shame this decision, so fundamentally important to every girl, woman, and family in the country, will slip by virtually unnoticed.

Trackbacks

  1. The religious rape of American women « Pied Type
  2. Judge strikes down restrictions on Plan B sales | Pied Type
  3. Plan B: Politics trumps science — again | Pied Type

"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." ~ Edmund Burke

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: