(Updated April 22, 2012 at 3:50 pm MDT)
I have a great respect for and love of native American Indian philosophy and religion, so it was deeply disappointing to learn that the quotation in my post It’s Earth Day (a re-post of Earth Day 2011) is not from Chief Seattle.
This was brought to my attention by my friend ImALibertarian, who sent me a link to the relevant page at Snopes.com, a site dedicated to exposing erroneous information on the Internet. According to Snopes, the quotation I used was actually penned by screenwriter Ted Perry in 1971 for the little-known 1972 film Home. Wikipedia confirms the information, as do numerous other sources.
I was doubly disappointed because I didn’t get the quotation from the Internet, purveyor of so much misinformation. I got it from a treasured little book in my library entitled Earth Prayers from Around the World: 366 Prayers, Poems, and Invocations for Honoring the Earth, edited by Elizabeth Roberts and Elias Amidon and published in 1991 by HarperOne. I perused the book for several hours last year to find the perfect quote for Earth Day, the one that best expressed my personal views. And with all there was to choose from — wouldn’t you know — I settled on the one clouded in controversy.
The book’s publication date is notable because all the sources cited by Snopes were published in 1991 or later. Apparently Perry, mistakenly thinking his name on the film was sufficient to confirm he’d written the speech, languished in the shadow of Chief Seattle for twenty years before the truth became widely known in 1991 after the publication of a New York Times best-selling children’s book entitled Brother Eagle, Sister Sky: A Message from Chief Seattle. The Times itself exposed the myth in a front page article in 1992.
I would prefer to think of the words as Chief Seattle’s; his name was the benediction I sought. But it would be a disservice to his memory and to Ted Perry not to set the record straight.
- Chief Seattle’s Screenwriter (huffingtonpost.com)
- The Truth of Chief Seattle (pantheist.net)
- Just Too Good to Be True: Another reason to beware of false eco-prophets (synaptic.bc.ca)
- American Indian Heritage Month ending (tombenjey.com)
- The Little Green Lie (schoolfile.homestead.com)